One of many hardest choices to make throughout Needle Knight Leda’s questline is suggesting anybody NPC between Hornsent or Thiollier in Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree. This section briefly occurs after Miquella’s Nice Rune (his enchantment) is damaged. Subsequent, Needle Knight Leda questions Hornsent and Thiollier’s loyalty towards “Kindly Miquella.”
As the good helper, you should recommend Leda select Hornsent or Thiollier. So, accordingly, she will decide and weed out a possible risk to Miquella and his devoted followers. Selecting any of the 2 NPCs has penalties you would possibly wish to find out about. Subsequently, we’ve got created this information so you’ll be able to determine essentially the most acceptable alternative between Hornsent and Thiollier in Elden Ring.
Who Ought to You Recommend Between Hornsent and Thiollier to Leda in Elden Ring
![Should You Suggest Hornsent Or Thiollier In Elden Ring? 1 Should You Suggest Hornsent Or Thiollier In Elden Ring](https://gamertweak.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Elden-Ring-Choosing-Hornsent.webp)
Earlier than we discover the implications, it must be famous that Leda will solely come to at least one conclusion: eliminating Hornsent. Even in the event you recommend Thiollier, she is going to deny and determine that Hornsent can threaten Miquella and his followers.
Anyway, that is what is going to occur in the event you nonetheless recommend both Hornsent or Thiollier to Leda in Elden Ring:
- Recommend Thiollier: As talked about, suggesting Thiollier to Leda will do nothing. Since Thiollier is very dedicated to St. Trina, which is similar factor as being dedicated to Miquella, Leda will spare him. Which means Thiollier shouldn’t be an precise risk to them.
- Recommend Hornsent: Suggesting Hornsent to Leda can be considerably convincing as she is going to take a while to consider it. With that stated, while you return to her after a protracted relaxation, she is going to make up her thoughts and determine to remove Hornsent.
- Recommend None: If you happen to determine in any other case, Leda will nonetheless contemplate eliminating Hornsent. So, regardless of whom you recommend, Hornsent will stay the principle wrongdoer for Leda.
![Should You Suggest Hornsent Or Thiollier In Elden Ring? 2 Should You Suggest Hornsent Or Thiollier In Elden Ring](https://gamertweak.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/summoning-hornsent.webp)
![Should You Suggest Hornsent Or Thiollier In Elden Ring? 2 Should You Suggest Hornsent Or Thiollier In Elden Ring](https://gamertweak.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/summoning-hornsent.webp)
The aftermath of suggesting Hornsent leaves you with two decisions thereafter – facet with Hornsent or Needle Knight Leda. Remember that whoever you select, the opposite can be eradicated, and so the quests associated to them will finish, too. When you attain the Shadowkeep, you’ll be able to summon and help both Hornsent or Leda. Accordingly, you’ll be able to summon any of those two and begin a boss combat.
If you happen to help Leda, Hornsent will die, and you can be rewarded with Falx, Caterpillar Masks, Braided Twine Gown, Braided Arm Wraps, and Dirty Loincloth. Later, while you relaxation on the Web site of Grace and discuss to Leda, she is going to reward you with a Lacerating Crossed-Tree Talisman. Then again, in the event you facet with Hornsent and kill Leda, you’ll obtain Ash of Conflict: Swift Slash and Leda’s Rune (40,000 Runes). Furthermore, additionally, you will be capable to summon Hornsent later in the course of the boss combat with Messmer.
Now that the implications for suggesting Hornsent or Thiollier in Elden Ring, progress and full the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC easily. For extra content material like this, you’ll be able to take a look at our devoted part for Elden Ring Guides on Gamer Tweak.